Hyannis, MA

Baxter's Boathouse

Pour Score 4.7 out of 5Pour Score

7ratings

100%would order again

Open in Maps Rate a drink here

House profile

OverallYour headline score for the drink4.7/5

Another?Would you order a second one100% yes

StrengthHow strong it tastesBoozy

SweetnessHow much sugar is in the glass—

FlavorTaste, balance, how it finishes4.7/5

PresentationGlass, garnish, the whole look4.1/5

VibeThe room, the bar, the service4.9/5

Drinks here

PainkillerPour Score 5 out of 5
1 rating100% would order again
MudslidePour Score 4.8 out of 5
5 ratings · ordered as Oreo Mudslide (3) and Mudslide (2)100% would order again
Rum PunchPour Score 4 out of 5
1 rating100% would order again

Best here

Pour Score 5 out of 5

Oreo Mudslide

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

I’m back for more!! Best around…

Emily RSep 19, 2026$18–21

Pour Score 5 out of 5

Oreo Mudslide

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

So good I came back for more 🎉

Emily RSep 4, 2026$14–17

Pour Score 5 out of 5

Mudslide

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

Oreo - BOMB

Emily RSep 4, 2026$14–17

Pour Score 5 out of 5

Painkiller

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

CarterSep 4, 2026$14–17

Pour Score 5 out of 5

Mudslide

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

CarterSep 4, 2026$14–17

Pour Score 4 out of 5

Oreo Mudslide

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

Holy guacamole - this thing just bent me over and dogged me crazy style! 9/10!

trounsSep 19, 2026$14–17

Pour Score 4 out of 5

Rum Punch

Baxter's Boathouse · Hyannis, MA

CarterSep 19, 2026$14–17

Own or run Baxter's Boathouse? Get free QR codes for your tables