Back to the feed
Painkiller at The Seafood Shanty, Edgartown, MA

Drink

Painkiller

The Seafood Shanty · Edgartown, MA

Pour Score 3 out of 5Pour Score
trouns, Sep 19, 2026
Price
$18–21
Strength
Balanced
Another?
No

Second one with the requested coconut cream. Almost indistinguishable from my first. Gave it one more rating higher because I’m like that.

The scorecard

OverallYour headline score for the drink3/5
Another?One was enoughNo
StrengthHow strong it tastesBalanced
SweetnessNot rated—
FlavorTaste, balance, how it finishes2/5
PresentationGlass, garnish, the whole look2/5
VibeThe room, the bar, the service4/5
View as a table
CriterionScore
Overall3 / 5
Another?No
Strength3 / 5
SweetnessNot rated
Flavor2 / 5
Presentation2 / 5
Vibe4 / 5
Find this barReport
Painkiller at The Seafood Shanty · How’s the Pour